Is 'Vital Proteins' Collagen Halal? (Bovine vs. Marine)

Walk into any Whole Foods, Target, or Sephora, and you will see the wall of Vital Proteins. Promoted by Jennifer Aniston and every fitness influencer on Instagram, “Collagen Peptides” promise glowing skin, stronger hair, and better joints.

But unlike Vitamin C or Zinc, Collagen is not a mineral. Collagen is an animal product. It is made by boiling down the hides (skin) and bones of cows or fish.

For a Muslim, this poses a huge question: Is the cow Halal?

Here is the definitive guide to the “Blue Tub” vs. the “Teal Tub” so you can glow without guilt.

The Blue Tub: Bovine Collagen (Cows) 🐄

This is the standard, unflavored bestseller.

• The Source: It is made from “Grass-Fed, Pasture-Raised Bovine Hides” (Cow Skin).
• The Halal Status: Doubtful (Mushbooh) to Avoid.
• The Detail: Vital Proteins (USA) is Kosher Certified (by Rabbi Noah Teitelbaum).
  • Why this is tricky: While Kosher meat is often acceptable to Muslims (Ahlul Kitab), the rules for collagen/gelatin in Judaism can be different. Some Kosher certifiers allow bovine hides from animals that were not ritually slaughtered, relying on the chemical transformation process.
• The Verdict: Unless the tub specifically says “Halal Certified” (which some export versions do, but US versions don’t), strict Zabiha eaters should avoid the Blue Tub. You cannot guarantee the cow was slaughtered according to Islamic rites.

The Teal Tub: Marine Collagen (Fish) 🐟

This is the one with the turquoise label.

• The Source: It is made from the scales of “wild-caught white fish” (usually Cod or Snapper).
• The Halal Status: 100% Halal.
• The Detail: Fish scales are Halal by consensus in almost all schools of thought (Sunni and Shia). There is no slaughter requirement for fish.
• The Verdict: Buy this one. It is slightly more expensive, but it offers the exact same beauty benefits (Type I Collagen) with zero religious ambiguity.

The Alternatives: Certified Halal Collagen

If you prefer bovine collagen (it’s often cheaper and tasteless) but want to be 100% sure it’s Zabiha, skip Vital Proteins and look for these brands:

1. Applied Nutrition (Critical Collagen): A UK brand often found in gym shops. They have a clear Halal Certification on the tub.
2. Great Lakes Gelatin (Green Can): Some batches are Kosher/Halal, but always check the current label.
3. Nuherbs: Specialized Halal collagen brands available online.

What about “Vegan Collagen”? 🌱

You might see “Vegan Collagen Builder” pills.

• The Truth: There is no such thing as vegan collagen. Plants do not produce collagen.
• What it is: These are just vitamins (Vitamin C, Zinc, Silica) that help your body produce its own collagen.
• Halal Status: 100% Halal. But don’t expect the same results as actual hydrolyzed peptides.

The Hidden “Beauty” Traps 💄

Collagen isn’t just in your smoothie. It’s in your face cream, your lip balm, and your “anti-aging” gummies.

• “Hydrolyzed Collagen” on a label: If it doesn’t say “Marine” or “Vegetable,” assume it is Pork or Non-Halal Beef.
• Gummies: Hair, Skin & Nails gummies almost always use Pork Gelatin as a binder.

  Gummy Alert: Check our guide on Gelatin in Sweets.

The Tayib Solution

You are standing in the supplement aisle. The font is tiny. “Bovine Hides.” “Porcine Gelatin.” “Marine Source.”

Don’t guess with your health.

Use Tayib to scan your supplements. We instantly filter:

• Pork Sources (Haram).
• Bovine Sources (Requires Halal Check).
• Marine/Fish Sources (Safe).

---